This paper presents a new application of failure modes and effects analysis (FMEA) on design processes. Our research develops error-proofing methods for the product development process to prevent serious design errors that can compromise project features, time to market, or cost. Design process FMEA is a systematic method which allows product development teams to proactively predict potential problems. The method decomposes the design process into six potential problem areas—knowledge, analysis, communication, execution, change, and organization errors—with a question-based FMEA approach. The paper explains the method, illustrates it through a case study, and discusses its effectiveness. The paper concludes with the proposed work to address design process error-proofing solutions.
Issue Section:
Research Papers
Keywords:
design,
error,
error proofing,
failure modes,
FMEA,
mistake,
process,
QFD,
task,
product development,
product design,
failure analysis
1.
Chao
, L. P.
, and Ishii
, K.
, 2004, “Design Error Classification and Knowledge Management
,” Journal of Knowledge Management Practice, 5, 1705
–9232
.2.
Chao
, L. P.
, and Ishii
, K.
, 2005, “Design Process Error-Proofing: Strategies for Reducing Quality Loss in Product Development
,” Proceedings of the ASME International Mechanical Engineering Congress and Exposition, Orlando, FL, November.3.
Chao
, L. P.
, Beiter
, K.
, and Ishii
, K.
, 2001, “Design Process Error-Proofing: International Industry Survey and Research Roadmap
,” Proceedings of the ASME DETC: DFM, Pittsburgh, PA.4.
Department of Defense, 1980,
Proceedings MIL-STD-1629A: Procedures for Performing a Failure Mode, Effects and Criticality Analysis
, Washington, D.C., November 24.5.
Gilchrist
, W.
, 1993, “Modeling Failure Modes and Effects
,” Int. J. Qual. Reliab. Manage.
0265-671X, 10
(5
), pp. 16
–23
.6.
Ormsby
, A.
, Hunt
, J.
, and Lee
, M.
, 1991, “Towards an Automated FMEA Assistant
,” Artificial Intelligence in Engineering
, Computational Mechanics Publications
, Southampton, Boston, MA, pp. 739
–752
.7.
Bednarz
, S.
, and Marriott
, D.
, 1988, “Efficient Analysis for FMEA
,” Proceedings of the 1988 IEEE Annual Reliability and Maintainability Symposium, Los Angeles, CA, pp. 416
–421
.8.
McKinney
, B.
, 1991, “FMECA, The Right Way
,” Proceedings of the 1991 IEEE Annual Reliability and Maintainability Symposium, Orlando, FL, pp. 253
–259
.9.
Kara-Zaitri
, C.
, Keller
, A.
, Barody
, I.
, and Fleming
, P.
, 1991, “An Improved FMEA Methodology
,” Proceedings of the 1991 IEEE Annual Reliability and Maintainability Symposium, Orlando, FL, pp. 248
–252
.10.
Bell
, D.
, Cox
, L.
, Jackson
, S.
, and Shaefer
, P.
, 1993, “Using Causal Reasoning for Automated Failure Modes & Effects Analysis (FMEA)
,” Proceedings of the 1992 IEEE Annual Reliability and Maintainability Symposium, pp. 343
–353
.11.
Umeda
, Y.
, Tomiyama
, T.
, and Yoshikawa
, Y.
, 1992, “A Design Methodology for a Self-Maintenance Machine Based on Functional Redundancy
,” Proceedings of the 4th International Conference on Design Theory and Methodology, Scottsdale, AZ, pp. 317
–324
.12.
Morjaria
, M.
, Simmons
, M.
, and Stillman
, J.
, 1992, “Development of Belief Networks Technology for Diagnostic Systems
,” General Electric Corporate Research and Development Technical Information Series
, GE CR & D
, Schnectady, NY.13.
Clark
, G.
, and Paasch
, R.
, 1994, “Diagnostic Modeling and Diagnosability Evaluation of Mechanical Systems
,” Proceedings of the ASME 6th International Conference on Design Theory and Methodology, Minneapolis, MN, pp. 179
–189
.14.
Kmenta
, S.
, Fitch
, P.
, and Ishii
, K.
, 1999, “Advanced Failure Modes and Effects Analysis of Complex Process
,” Proceedings of the ASME DETC: DFM. Las Vegas, NV.15.
Rhee
, S.
, and Ishii
, K.
, 2004, “Predicting Cost of Poor Quality and Reliability for Systems Using Failure Modes and Effects Analysis
,” Proceedings of the ASME IMECE, Anaheim, CA, November.16.
Kmenta
, S.
, Ishii
, K.
, and Cheldelin
, B.
, 2003, “Assembly FMEA: A Simplified Method for Identifying Assembly Errors
,” Proceedings of the ASME International Mechanical Engineering Congress and Exposition, Washington, D.C., November.17.
Chao
, L. P.
, and Ishii
, K.
, 2003, “Design Process Error-Proofing: Development of Automated Error-Proofing Information Systems
,” Proceedings of the ASME DETC: DAC, Chicago, IL.18.
Chao
, L. P.
, and Ishii
, K.
, 2004, “Challenges and Methods in the Quantification of Design Errors and Solution Elements
,” Proceedings of the ASME IMECE, Anaheim, CA.19.
Williams
, J. C.
, 1986, “HEART: A Proposed Method for Assessing and Reducing Human Error
,” Proceedings of the 9th Advances in Reliability Technology Symposium, University of Bradford, Bradford, UK.20.
Waldron
, K. J.
, Vohnout
, V. J.
, Pery
, A.
, and McGhee
, R. B.
, 1984, “Configuration Design of the Adaptive Suspension Vehicle
,” Int. J. Robot. Res.
0278-3649, 3
(2
).21.
Waldron
, M. B.
, and Waldron
, K. J.
, 1988, “A Time Sequence Study of a Complex Mechanical System Design
,” Des. Stud.
0142-694X, 9
(2
), pp. 95
–106
.22.
Pugh
, D. R.
, Ribble
, E. A.
, Vohnout
, V. J.
, Bihari
, T. E.
, Walliser
, T. M.
, Patterson
, M. R.
, and Waldron
, K. J.
, 1990, “A Technical Description of the Adaptive Suspension Vehicle
,” Int. J. Robot. Res.
0278-3649, 9
(2
), pp. 24
–42
.23.
Chao
, L. P.
, Tumer
, I.
, and Ishii
, K.
, 2005, “Design Process Error-Proofing: Lessons from and Challenges for NASA
,” Proceedings of the ASME International Mechanical Engineering Congress and Exposition, Orlando, FL, November.24.
Abu-Hanna
, A.
, Benjamins
, R.
, and Jansweijer
, W.
, 1991, “Device Understanding and Modeling for Diagnosis
,” IEEE Expert
0885-9000, 6
(2
), pp. 26
–32
.25.
Chen
, Y.
, Feng
, P.
, He
, B.
, Lin
, Z.
, and Xie
, Y.
, 2006 “Automated Conceptual Design of Mechanisms Using Improved Morphological Matrix
,” J. Mech. Des.
1050-0472, 123
(3
), pp. 516
–526
.26.
Cohen
, L.
, 1995, Quality Function Deployment: How to Make QFD Work for You
, Addison-Wesley
, Reading, MA.27.
Gupta
, A. K.
, and Wileman
, D. L.
, 1990, “Accelerating the Development of Technology-Based New Products
,” California Manage. Rev.
0008-1256, Winter.28.
Hamscher
, W.
, Console
, L.
, and de Kleer
, J.
, eds., 1992, Readings in Model-based Diagnosis
, Morgan Kaufmann
, San Mateo, CA.29.
Hari
, A.
, and Weiss
, M. P.
, 1999, “CFMA-An Effective FMEA tool for Analysis and Selection of the Concept for a New Product
,” Proceedings of the ASME DETC: DTM, Las Vegas, NV.30.
Hinckley
, C. M.
, 2001, Make No Mistake
, Productivity Press
, Portland, OR.31.
Ishii
, K.
, ed., 2003, ME317 Course Reader
, Stanford University Press
, Stanford, CA.32.
Kokkolaras
, M.
, Mourelatos
, Z. P.
, and Papalambros
, P. Y.
, 2006, “Design Optimization of Hierarchically Decomposed Multilevel Systems Under Uncertainty
,” J. Mech. Des.
1050-0472, 123
(2
), pp. 503
–508
.33.
Leveson
, N. G.
, 1995, Safeware: System Safety and Computers
, Addison-Wesley
, Reading, MA.34.
Levy
, M.
, and Salvadori
, M.
, 1992, Why Buildings Fall Down
, Norton & Company
, New York.35.
Nikkan Kogyo Shimbum Ltd./Factory Magazine, ed., 1988,
Poka-yoke: Improving Product Quality by Preventing Defects
, Productivity Press
, Cambridge, MA.36.
Norman
, D. A.
, 1988, The Design of Everyday Things
, Doubleday/Currency
, New York.37.
Perrow
, C.
, 1999, Normal Accidents
, Princeton University Press
, Princeton, NJ.38.
Petroski
, H.
, 1992, To Engineer is Human
, Vintage Books
, New York.39.
Price
, J. C.
, Pugh
, R. D.
, Wilson
, S. M.
, and Snooke
, N.
, 1995, “The Flame System: Automating Electrical Failure Mode & Effect Analysis (FMEA)
,” Proceedings of IEEE Annual Reliability and Maintainability Symposium, Washington, DC.40.
Reason
, J.
, 1990, Human Error
, Cambridge University Press
, Cambridge, UK.41.
Reason
, J.
, 1997, Managing the Risks of Organizational Accidents
, Ashgate Publishing Ltd.
, Aldershot, UK.42.
Sankar
, N. R.
, and Prabhu
, B. S.
, 2000, “A Revised Matrix FMEA Technique Based on Fuzzy Logic
,” Proceedings of the ASME DETC: RSAFP, Baltimore, MD.43.
Sherwood
, M.
, and Shu
, L. H.
, 2000, “Modified FMEA Using Analysis of Automotive Remanufacturer Waste Streams to Support Design for Remanufacture
,” Proceedings of the ASME DETC: CIE, Baltimore, MD.44.
Song
, S. M.
, and Waldron
, K. J.
, 1988, Machines That Walk: The Adaptive Suspension Vehicle
, MIT Press
, Cambridge, MA.45.
Tumer
, I. Y.
, and Mehr
, A. F.
, 2006, “Risk-Based Decision-Making for Managing Resources During the Design of Complex Space Exploration Systems
,” J. Mech. Des.
1050-0472, 123
(4
), pp. 657
–1022
.46.
Wang
, J. D.
, and Howard
, I. M.
, 2005 “Error Analysis on Finite Element Modeling of Involute Spur Gears
,” J. Mech. Des.
1050-0472, 123
(1
), pp. 90
–97
.Copyright © 2007
by American Society of Mechanical Engineers
You do not currently have access to this content.
