Abstract
Despite the immense environmental, technical, and financial promise of distributed generation (DG) technologies, they still constitute a very small percentage of electricity capacity in the United States. This manuscript answers the apparently paradoxical question: Why do technologies that offer such impressive benefits also find the least use? Going beyond technical explanations of problems related to system control, higher capital costs, and environmental compliance, this paper focuses on sociotechnical barriers related to utility preferences, business practices, regulatory bias, and consumer values. The approach helps us understand the glossing over of DG technologies, and identifies the impediments that policymakers must overcome if they are to find wider use.
References
1.
U.S. Department of Energy
,
2007, “The Potential
Benefits of Distributed Generation and Rate-Related Issues That May Impede
Their Expansion
,” U.S. Department of Energy, Washington,
DC.2.
Munson
,
R.
,
2006, “Yes, in My
Backward: Distributed Electric Power
,” Issues in Science and
Technology, Winter, p. 51
.3.
Onsite Energy Corporation
,
2001, “Assessment of
On-Site Power Opportunities in the Industrial Sector
,”
Department of Energy Office of Industrial Technology, Final Report, Mar., p.
ES
-1
.4.
U.S. Energy Information Administration
,
2002, “The Role of
Distributed Generation in U.S. Electricity Markets
,” http://www.eia.doe.gov/oiaf/speeches/figure_8.html.5.
LaCommare
,
K.
,
Edwards
,
J.
,
Gumermann
,
E.
, and
Marnay
,
C.
,
2005, “Distributed
Generation Potential of the U.S. Commercial Sector
,”
Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory, Report No. LBNL-57919, Berkeley,
CA.6.
Sovacool
, B.
K.
, 2006,
“The Power Production Paradox: Revealing the Socio-Technical
Impediments to Distributed Generation Technologies
,” Ph.D.
thesis, Virginia Polytechnic Institute and State University, Blacksburg,
VA.7.
Ackermann
,
T.
,
Andersson
,
G.
, and
Soder
,
L.
,
2000, “Distributed
Generation: A Definition
,” Electr. Power Syst.
Res.
0378-7796, 57
, pp.
195
–204
. 8.
Kauhaniemi
,
K.
,
Komulainen
,
R.
, and
Samuelsson
,
O.
,
2004, “Distributed
Generation: New Technical Solutions Required in the Distribution
System
,” http://powersystems.tkk.fi/nordac2004/papers/nordac2004_kauhaniemi_et_al_paper.pdf.9.
Madlener
,
R.
, and
Wohlgemuth
,
N.
,
1999, “Small is
Sometimes Beautiful: The Case of Distributed Generation in Competitive
Energy Markets
,” Proceedings of the First
Austrian-Czech-German Conference on Energy Market Liberalization in the
Central and Eastern Europe
, Prague, Czech
Republic
, Sept. 6–8, pp.
95
–96
.10.
Goett
,
A.
, and
Farmer
,
R.
,
2003, “Prospects for
Distributed Electricity Generation: A CBO Paper
,”
Congressional Budget Office, Washington, DC, p.
6
.11.
Meherwan
, P.
B.
, 2002,
Handbook for Cogeneration and Combined Cycle Power Plants
,
ASME
, New
York
, p. 25
.12.
Brooks
,
S.
,
Elswick
,
B.
, and
Elliott
, R.
N.
, 2006,
“Combined Heat and Power: Connecting the Gap Between Markets
and Utility Interconnection and Tariff Practices
,” ACEEE,
Report No. IE062, Washington, DC.13.
Wiser
, W.
H.
, 2000,
Energy Resources: Occurrence, Production, Conversion, Use
,
Springer
, New
York
, pp.
198
–199
.14.
Nordin
,
A.
,
1994, “Chemical
Elemental Characteristics of Biomass Fuels
,” Biomass
Bioenergy
0961-9534, 6
, pp.
339
–347
; Sovacool
,
B. K.
, 2006,
“The Power Production Paradox: Revealing the Socio-Technical
Impediments to Distributed Generation Technologies
,” Ph.D.
thesis, Virginia Polytechnic Institute and State University, Blacksburg,
VA..15.
Petchers
,
N.
,
2003, Combined Heating, Cooling
and Power Handbook: Technologies and Applications
,
The Fairmount
, New
York
; Nakarado
,
G.
, and
Thomas
,
H.
,
2003, “Combined Heat and
Power, Revisited
,” Public Utilities Fortnightly No. 141,
Sept. 1, pp. 39
–41
; Siddiqui
, A.
S.
, Firestone
, R.
M.
, Ghosh
,
S.
,
Stadler
,
M.
,
Edwards
, J.
L.
, and Marnay
,
C.
,
2003, “Distributed
Energy Resources With Combined Heat and Power Applications
,”
The Ernest Orlando Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory Report, Jun.; Willis
,
H. L.
, and Scott
, W.
G.
, 2000,
Distributed Power Generation: Planning and Evaluation
,
Dekker
, New
York
.16.
Mason
, V.
C.
, 2004,
“Environmentally Unfriendly Wind Power—A Personal
Opinion
,” http://www.wind-watch.org/documents/wp-content/uploads/mason-2005-10.rtf,
p. 3
.17.
McDermott
, T.
E.
, and Dugan
, R.
D.
, 2003,
“PQ, Reliability, and DG
,” IEEE Industry
Applications Magazine, Sept., pp.
17
–23
.18.
National Energy Policy Development Group
,
2001, “Reliable,
Affordable, and Environmentally Sound Energy for America’s
Future
,” Whitehouse Printing Services, Washington,
DC.19.
U.S. Department of Energy
,
2002, “Homeland
Security: Safeguarding America’s Future With Energy Efficiency and Renewable
Energy Technologies
,” Washington, DC.20.
Natural Gas Organization
,
2007, “Natural Gas
Distribution
,” http://www.naturalgas.org/naturalgas/distribution.asp.21.
Parker
, N.
C.
, 2004,
“Using Natural Gas Transmission Pipeline Costs to Estimate
Hydrogen Pipeline Costs
,” University of California, Report
No. UCD-ITS-RR-04–35, Davis.22.
Sovacool
, B.
K.
, and Cooper
,
C.
,
2006, “Green Means Go: A
Colorful Approach to a National Renewable Portfolio
Standard
,” Electr. J.
1040-6190, 19
(7
), pp.
19
–32
.23.
Strachan
,
N.
, and
Farrell
,
A.
,
2006, “Emissions From
Distributed vs. Centralized Generation: The Importance of System
Performance
,” Energy Policy
0301-4215, 34
(17
), pp.
2677
–2689
.24.
Williams
,
E.
,
James
,
C.
, and
Tubiolo
,
T.
,
2003, “Distributed
Generation and a Forecast of Its Growth and Effects on the New York State
Electric System From 2001 to 2020
,” Center for Clean Air
Policy, Washington, DC.25.
Silveira
, J.
L.
, de Carbalho
, J.
A.
, and Villela
, A.
D. C.
, 2007,
“Combined Cycle Versus One Thousand Diesel Power Plants:
Pollutant Emissions, Ecological Efficiency and Economic
Analysis
,” Renewable Sustainable Energy
Rev.
1364-0321, 11
, pp.
524
–535
. 26.
Heath
, G.
A.
, Granvold
, P.
W.
, Hoats
, A.
S.
, and Nazaroff
,
W. W.
, 2005,
“Quantifying the Air Pollution Exposure Consequences of
Distributed Electricity Generation
,” University of
California Energy Institute, Berkeley, CA.27.
Hirsh
, R.
F.
, 1989,
Technology and Transformation in the American Electric Utility
Industry
, Cambridge University
Press
, Cambridge,
UK
.28.
Feinstein
, C.
D.
, Orans
,
R.
, and
Chapel
, S.
W.
, 1997,
“The Distributed Utility: A New Electric Utility Planning and
Pricing Paradigm
,” Annu. Rev. Energy
Environ.
1056-3466, 22
, pp.
157
–162
.29.
Makarov
,
Y.
,
2002, “California ISO
Wind Generation Forecasting Service Design and Experience
,”
California Independent Systems Operator Report, http://www.caiso.com/docs/2002/06/12/2002061211030528205.pdf.30.
Karmis
,
M.
,
Abiecunas
,
J.
,
Sovacool
,
B.
, and
Hirsh
,
R.
,
2005, “A Study of
Increased Use of Renewable Energy Resources in Virginia
,”
Virginia Center for Coal and Energy Research, http://www.energy.vt.edu/Publications/Incr_Use_Renew_Energy_VA_rev1.pdf.31.
Capehart
, B.
L.
, Mehta
,
P.
, and
Turner
,
W.
,
2003, “Distributed
Generation and Your Energy Future
,” Cogeneration and
Distributed Generation Journal
,
18
(4
), pp.
17
–33
.32.
Wan
, Y.
H.
, and Parsons
, B.
K.
, 1993,
“Factors Relevant to Utility Integration of Intermittent
Renewable Technologies
,” National Renewable Energy
Laboratory, Report No. NREL∕TP-463–4953, Golden, CO, http://www.nrel.gov/docs/legosti/old/4953.pdf33.
Bruno
, J.
C.
, Massagues
,
L.
, and
Coronas
,
A.
,
2004, “Stand-Alone and
Grid-Connected Performance Analysis of a Regenerative Micro Gas Turbine
Cogeneration Plant
,” Proc. Inst. Mech. Eng., Part
A
0957-6509, 218
, pp.
15
–22
. 34.
Strachan
,
N.
, and
Farrell
,
A.
,
2006, “Emissions From
Distributed vs. Centralized Generation: The Importance of System
Performance
,” Energy Policy
0301-4215, 34
(17
), pp.
2677
–2689
.35.
Hadley
, S.
W.
, Van Dyke
, J.
W.
, Moore
, W.
P.
, and Stovall
, T.
K.
, 2003,
“Quantitative Assessment of Distributed Energy Resources
Benefits
,” Oak Ridge National Laboratory Report No.
ORNL∕TM-2003∕20, Oak Ridge, TN.36.
Strachan
,
N.
, and
Dowlatabadi
,
H.
,
2002, “Distributed
Generation and Distribution Utilities
,” Energy
Policy
0301-4215, 30
, pp.
649
–661
.37.
Primary Energy Incorporated
,
2006,
“Projects—Cokeenrgy LLC
,” http://www.primaryenergy.com/facilities/cokenergy.htm.38.
39.
PJM Interconnection LLC
,
2005, “OATT Attachment
Feasibility Study Agreement Form
,” http://www.pjm.com/planning/expansion-planning/form-oatt-feas-study.html.40.
Russell
,
C.
,
2004, “Barriers to
Industrial Energy Cost Control: The Competitor Within
,”
Alliance to Save Energy, Washington, DC, pp.
1
–2
.41.
Pasqualetti
, M.
J.
, 2000,
“Morality, Space, and the Power of Wind-Energy
Landscapes
,” Geogr. Rev.
0016-7428, 90
(3
), pp.
384
–386
.Copyright © 2008
by American Society of Mechanical Engineers
You do not currently have access to this content.
